GTA4 VS. Metal Gear 4

[Sano-kun]

I love all MGs but I can't seem to get over how awesome the little things on GTA4. Gotta love the hookers and all it's fabulous entertainment.

So, who gets your vote?

[nomhak]

Comparing the two games is a stupid thing to do. They are completely different genres, so it'll be a battle in game genre preferences, in which GTA would win.

[sleeping_ninja]

let not get to wild here it depends what do you mean, see MGS4 will be way better than GTA4
even though the hookers are good but they start to get pretty boring afterwards, gta4 is to predictable and MGS4 always excite and complex their games to make it more unpredictable so
I'm going to go with MGS4

[FireWrath]

Neither really has reply value, though GTA IV will suck up more time, so you'll enjoy that one longer.

[Zombii]

MGS4 seems to be building up a lot of hype.

Yes - a lot of fanboys will weep.

[lain]

This is fail. GTAIV failed... MGS4 will probably fail but I'll play it.. the end the loser is you, the consumer.

[FireWrath]

The game will probably be short though, which is the sad part. Too many games end up being either too short, or long but too easy, so I don't get to enjoy them as much. Resident Evil was great, but it was too easy, and even though I loved, I ended up just feeling depressed as to how quickly I beat everything on the first try. Prince of Persia games are a bit more difficult, but they take less than six hours to beat. Either way, no time to actually enjoy the games :/

[Sano-kun]

Originally Posted by nomhak

Comparing the two games is a stupid thing to do. They are completely different genres, so it'll be a battle in game genre preferences, in which GTA would win.

Actually, it's not a comparison between two genres of games, I'm basically leaning forward on which people would spend their money on.

I am quite hesitant which game I should spend my money on so I'm asking the general public which they think would be the best bang for my buck, generally speaking.

[nomhak]

Originally Posted by Sano-kun

Actually, it's not a comparison between two genres of games, I'm basically leaning forward on which people would spend their money on.

I am quite hesitant which game I should spend my money on so I'm asking the general public which they think would be the best bang for my buck, generally speaking.

Depends on which you've followed, but if that is not the case, then its all gameplay Dependant, and which styles of games you like.

Both are rather storyline intensive, but MGS needs some background information (from all the other games) to really understand and appreciate the game.

[Condemned92]

MG4 is better